Book Review of Snow Flower and the Secret Fan
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan
by: Lisa See
It is rare these days that I have the opportunity to read a book and simply enjoy the act of reading. As so many who aspire to become a recognized writer, I spend much of my reading energy dissecting the book, understanding how the author so masterfully pulled off their craft. That is why I was so impressed with Lisa See’s latest novel, Snow Flower and the Secret Fan. Her beautifully woven story took me on a journey and introduced me to such rich characters that I foregone my normal reading habits to simply enjoy the story.
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is a powerful story about relationships, regrets, and life-long friendships. While set in a traditional Chinese world, almost anyone can relate to the themes and emotions in this book.
This story begins with Lily, a elderly Chinese woman in the mid to late 18th century, as she reflects upon her life as a woman. As most traditional women of her time, her passage to womanhood begins with her foot-binding. The success or failure of that sets in motion the luck of her future. With beautifully bound feet and good protocol, she is guaranteed a good husband and many sons.
Because of her good feet, she is given the opportunity to have a laotong, “old same”, named Snow Flower. This relationship is with another girl and is as sacred as a marriage as they are keep each other company through life. They converse using the secret women’s writing known as nu shu.
Nu shu was a means of communication used by women in the Hunan province. This style of writing was more curved and fanciful than traditional Chinese calligraphy (men’s writing). Written on objects, sown into handkerchiefs, this writing looked more like art than literature. There were fewer characters that men’s writing, relying on the phonetics and context to convey the meaning. Many of these were also sung, having a rhythmic beat to the words. Not many examples of this art remains today. Many pieces were burned upon a person’s death, as was the tradition of the time. The art was further devastated during the Cultural Revolution where it was banned and all but died out until it was discovered again in 1983. Today it is viewed as a national historical treasure, with even a museum dedicated to the few remaining examples.
Lily and Snow Flower's laotong begins with a fan which they continue throughout their life to write messages to each other back and forth. While this relationship starts cheery and bright, the story progresses through the events that lead to Lily’s regrets in life as an old woman and how she betrayed her laotong. Ms. See does a wonderful job of describing the events of Lily’s life with so much color you feel as if you’re sitting along side her. For instance, as her feet are bound, you can feel her agony and wonder how they endured. All the while, Ms. See drops reminders into the story that manage to keep reminding the reader we are viewing this world through a window. Many of the customs she describes I have heard time and time again from my parents; yet the way Ms. See describes them, I feel like I’m learning about them on some new and more personal level.
I picked up Snow Flower and the Secret Fan on a whim, having seen it for several weeks displayed at my local bookstore. However, after not being able to put it down until I completed it, I do not regret taking the time to pick this up. This is a wonderful book and a spectacular story that captures much of the intricacies of a woman’s position in Chinese culture.
by: Lisa See
It is rare these days that I have the opportunity to read a book and simply enjoy the act of reading. As so many who aspire to become a recognized writer, I spend much of my reading energy dissecting the book, understanding how the author so masterfully pulled off their craft. That is why I was so impressed with Lisa See’s latest novel, Snow Flower and the Secret Fan. Her beautifully woven story took me on a journey and introduced me to such rich characters that I foregone my normal reading habits to simply enjoy the story.
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is a powerful story about relationships, regrets, and life-long friendships. While set in a traditional Chinese world, almost anyone can relate to the themes and emotions in this book.
This story begins with Lily, a elderly Chinese woman in the mid to late 18th century, as she reflects upon her life as a woman. As most traditional women of her time, her passage to womanhood begins with her foot-binding. The success or failure of that sets in motion the luck of her future. With beautifully bound feet and good protocol, she is guaranteed a good husband and many sons.
Because of her good feet, she is given the opportunity to have a laotong, “old same”, named Snow Flower. This relationship is with another girl and is as sacred as a marriage as they are keep each other company through life. They converse using the secret women’s writing known as nu shu.
Nu shu was a means of communication used by women in the Hunan province. This style of writing was more curved and fanciful than traditional Chinese calligraphy (men’s writing). Written on objects, sown into handkerchiefs, this writing looked more like art than literature. There were fewer characters that men’s writing, relying on the phonetics and context to convey the meaning. Many of these were also sung, having a rhythmic beat to the words. Not many examples of this art remains today. Many pieces were burned upon a person’s death, as was the tradition of the time. The art was further devastated during the Cultural Revolution where it was banned and all but died out until it was discovered again in 1983. Today it is viewed as a national historical treasure, with even a museum dedicated to the few remaining examples.
Lily and Snow Flower's laotong begins with a fan which they continue throughout their life to write messages to each other back and forth. While this relationship starts cheery and bright, the story progresses through the events that lead to Lily’s regrets in life as an old woman and how she betrayed her laotong. Ms. See does a wonderful job of describing the events of Lily’s life with so much color you feel as if you’re sitting along side her. For instance, as her feet are bound, you can feel her agony and wonder how they endured. All the while, Ms. See drops reminders into the story that manage to keep reminding the reader we are viewing this world through a window. Many of the customs she describes I have heard time and time again from my parents; yet the way Ms. See describes them, I feel like I’m learning about them on some new and more personal level.
I picked up Snow Flower and the Secret Fan on a whim, having seen it for several weeks displayed at my local bookstore. However, after not being able to put it down until I completed it, I do not regret taking the time to pick this up. This is a wonderful book and a spectacular story that captures much of the intricacies of a woman’s position in Chinese culture.
This site needs an editor - click to learn more!
Related Articles
Editor's Picks Articles
Top Ten Articles
Previous Features
Site Map
Content copyright © 2023 by Caroline Baker. All rights reserved.
This content was written by Caroline Baker. If you wish to use this content in any manner, you need written permission. Contact
BellaOnline Administration
for details.